Diamond Color Clarity: What Matters More When Choosing a Stone?

Color is the degree of tint you see, from colorless to yellow or brown. The best stones are those that show a complete lack of color.

Clarity refers to the inclusions or blemishes found within or atop the diamond. It is graded from flawless down to stones with obvious inclusions.

For color and clarity, U.S. Jewelers are using the GIA scale. This new scale provides buyers greater confidence and security by easily allowing them to see what they are buying.

Knowing both color and clarity helps people in cities like Los Angeles pick the right diamond for their style and budget. The last section will discuss how each section ranks in terms of importance to everyday decisions.

Key Takeaways

• Knowing the 4 Cs—cut, color, clarity, carat weight—will help you make smart diamond buying decisions in Canada.

• Diamond color and clarity are two of the most important factors affecting appearance and value. How to balance these tradeoffs is entirely up to your own preference and budget.

• Canadian diamond grading standards are among the strictest and most accurate in the industry, so always search for certification from recognized institutions or agencies.

• Comparing diamonds side by side and viewing them under different lighting conditions helps reveal subtle differences in color and clarity.

• By educating yourself on grading reports and collaborating with a knowledgeable Canadian jeweller, you can feel confident in receiving expert guidance and quality products.

• You’ll be much happier with your choice and investment if you take the time to understand what you’re looking at in person.

What Are Diamond Basics?

Diamonds have four main traits that shape their look and worth: cut, color, clarity, and carat weight. These are known as the 4 Cs. Each of these qualities determines how a diamond sparkles and how much it’s worth.

Understanding these basics will help buyers identify what is most important for their uses and budget. It’s a lot easier shopping for diamonds when you understand how these features interact with one another and more importantly, why it matters.

Quick Look at the 4 Cs

The 4 Cs provide a complete picture of a diamond’s nature. Each one may have a specific purpose, but collectively they produce the sum total to the overall impression.

Here’s a short list:

• Cut: How well the diamond is shaped and polished. The better the cut grade, the more sparkle and brilliance your diamond will have. Whether you choose a round brilliant or an emerald cut, well-cut diamonds have that fiery appearance.

• Color: The less color a diamond has, the higher its grade. Consequently, pure, colorless stones are the rarest and most highly valued. In fact, the majority of diamonds fall somewhere along this yellowish or brownish line.

• Clarity: This means how free the stone is from tiny flaws inside or on the surface. Less inclusions or other flaws result in improvements in the clarity and increase the price.

• Carat Weight: How much the diamond weighs. One carat equals 0.2 grams. As you can see, larger stones are rarer and therefore more expensive.

It’s a wise person that finds a balance among all four. For instance, a high-cut 1-carat diamond will appear more brilliant than a 2-carat diamond with poor clarity.

Why These Factors Matter Together

No single “C” paints the complete picture. A big diamond that’s dull, or a clear diamond that’s yellow, won’t catch your eye. Clarity and color usually work together to determine the value.

To get the best value, consider the four Cs together as a group.

Canadian Diamond Grading Standards

Canada adheres to very rigorous grading standards, comparable to the international standards. Laboratories enjoy grading cut, color, and clarity using specific scales.

While Canadian diamond grading adheres to international standards, it’s wise to look for certification from reputable organizations. This verifies your diamond’s actual grade, so you can be confident that you’re getting what you paid for.

What Is Diamond Color?

Diamond color is one of the 4 C’s that shape a diamond’s quality and price, right up there with cut, clarity, and carat. Color is the term used to describe the body color of a diamond, which is most often a shade of yellow or brown. This hue can influence a diamond’s luminosity (brightness) and scintillation (fiery look).

You’ll be able to see it even before clarity! For most buyers, color makes a more noticeable difference than small inclusions.

In diamond grading, color is rated on a scale from D to Z. D is the highest grade, meaning pure and colorless—these diamonds will appear icy and clear. As you go down the scale to Z, you notice increasingly yellow or brown.

Generally, most diamonds available in retail stores will be near colorless and in the G to J range. Pure colorless diamond stones are extremely rare and command a much higher price point. In reality, even just a one step improvement in color grade could result in thousands of dollars difference in the price.

You may not notice any difference with the unaided eye between neighboring grades. Of course, diamonds can be other colors too—not only white. Others exhibit strong colors such as blue, pink, or yellow. These “fancy” diamonds adhere to separate grading criteria, and their scarcity renders them desirable for unique statement jewelry.

The Official Color Scale Explained

Subtle differences in grade can result in huge price increases, particularly at the top. A D color diamond would generally have a much larger premium attached to it than an F color diamond. Incredibly, the difference is invisible to most people without a jeweler’s loupe.

How Color Affects Diamond Look

Look at how color affects diamond appearance. Color contributes to a diamond’s overall pattern of sparkle. Colorless diamonds reflect light better, making them appear more brilliant.

Light is another major factor. Depending on a diamond’s setting, it can hide or highlight its color. Yellow gold can cover up a slight yellow hue, whereas white gold or platinum will magnify it.

Beyond White: Fancy Colors

Fancy colored diamonds—like pinks, blues, and even greens—are graded based on the intensity and purity of their color. These are very rare and often sell for premium prices. Their vibrant colors have made them extremely popular for modern, statement jewelry.

Our Take: Best Color Grades?

For engagement rings, most diamond shoppers choose color grades G through J for the best combination of value and appearance. It depends on what you like. Personal taste, style, and budget are all key components.

For some, an icy white diamond is the dream; for others, nothing comes close to a cozy diamond.

What Is Diamond Clarity?

Diamond clarity is one of the four Cs — cut, color, clarity — that determine a diamond’s overall quality and value. It indicates the location and nature of the inclusions and blemishes if any exist.

These inclusions and blemishes can have a bearing impact on a diamond’s beauty. Diamond clarity impacts how light travels through a diamond, and therefore its fire and brilliance. Even small inclusions can change the stone’s appearance and worth.

Virtually all diamonds have such imperfections, although those may not be visible without magnification. Clarity grades define these flaws in terms of how they impact the look and market value of the diamond, which helps buyers make informed purchases.

Understanding the Clarity Grades

Diamonds are graded on a scale from Flawless (FL), the highest and most perfect grade, down to Included (I3). One grade up from Perfect, each grade represents how obvious and abundant the flaws appear.

Here’s a quick breakdown:

• Flawless (FL): No inclusions or blemishes under 10x magnification.

• Internally Flawless (IF): No inclusions, only tiny surface blemishes.

• Very Very Slightly Included (VVS1–VVS2): Minute inclusions, very hard to spot even for experts.

• Very Slightly Included (VS1–VS2): Minor inclusions, difficult to see with 10x magnification.

• Slightly Included (SI1–SI2): Noticeable inclusions under magnification, may be visible to the naked eye.

• Included (I1–I3): Severe inclusions can impact durability.

Clarity is important in determining a diamond’s visual beauty. As a rule of thumb, a diamond graded at VS and above will appear “clean” to the naked eye. Diamonds at lower grades will have visible flaws.

Common Diamond Imperfections Found

Common Diamond Imperfections Found Inclusions may appear as crystals, feathers, or clouds within the diamond. Blemishes can be defined as scratches or chips on the stone’s surface.

Gemologists will use magnifying tools to identify and grade these characteristic marks. More inclusions decrease a diamond’s clarity grade and cost, although microscopic blemishes aren’t visible without magnification.

What "Eye-Clean" Really Means

An “eye-clean” diamond is one that you cannot see any visible inclusions without magnification at a normal viewing distance. Most VS and SI stones will be eye-clean as in, their inclusions won’t be visible under normal wear.

This is why personal inspection is so important; each diamond is unique.

Closer Look: VVS Clarity Insights

VVS clarity diamonds contain very, very small inclusions that are only visible to expert graders under magnification. Their rarity and near-perfect appearance give them immense value.

Buyers will be hard-pressed to find these imperfections, even under magnification.

Closer Look: VS Clarity Insights

VS clarity diamonds feature minor inclusions that are typically not seen without 10x magnification. These stones provide a perfect balance between quality and cost, which is why they are often the go-to choice for engagement rings.

Closer Look: SI Clarity Insights

SI diamonds will display more apparent and detectable inclusions, at times even visible to the naked eye. They’re the most cost-effective, giving you the best bang for your buck if you’re looking to spend less, particularly when the imperfections are minor and strategically located.

How Color and Clarity Interact?

When you are looking for a diamond, color and clarity play a vital role in the appearance and value of the diamond itself. These two traits don’t function independently—each one can alter your perception of the other. Combined, they influence sparkle, price, and general beauty.

Whether you’re shopping in Los Angeles or any large metropolis, knowing how these features work together is important. It gives you the confidence to buy smart.

1. Does Clarity Change Color View?

Clarity refers to the degree of purity in a diamond when viewed at 10x magnification. Inclusions—small marks or imperfections—can prevent light from passing through or even introduce a bit of cloudiness. This can cause a diamond with an otherwise excellent or ideal color grade to appear dull.

Conversely, certain clarity grades conceal subtle color shades when inclusions are positioned correctly. Sunlight, indoor LEDs, and even phone flashlights can help display or obscure color and inclusions.

2. Balancing Color, Clarity, and Value

Unfortunately, achieving both great color and clarity is rarely attainable without spending big bucks. Most buyers prefer the colorless diamond with high clarity. Some buyers are willing to accept a stone that has a fair number of inclusions but superb color.

That’s where value comes in, determining what’s most valuable to you. Request to see stones in comparison with one another before purchasing.

3. How Cut Impacts Color and Clarity

A high-quality cut will conceal minuscule imperfections and reduce color visibility. Cuts that are brighter, like the round or princess styles, reflect a lot of sparkle, making small defects less noticeable.

4. Lighting's Effect on Appearance

Diamonds will appear differently in the sun, in office lighting, or under the store display. Always see stones in multiple lighting environments. Natural light provides the most accurate picture.

5. Busting Color and Clarity Myths

The truth is that not all “flawless” diamonds actually appear superior to their lower-grade counterparts. Not all inclusions are visible, even under magnification. Don’t just guess based on assumptions.

Trust expert grading.

6. Lab-Grown vs. Natural Differences

That’s because lab-grown diamonds tend to have less inclusions and more uniform color. Compared to natural stones of the same grades, they are much less expensive. Both types have their fans, but lab-grown options are definitely greener.

7. Grading Tech: Getting More Accurate

High-end tools such as microscopes and imaging software, for example, provide more accurate grading. These improvements reduce grading discrepancies and increase consistency.

8. How Market Demand Shifts Value

Market trends are powerful forces that can quickly alter the things buyers desire. Currently, demand for high-clarity or unique color stones can drive their prices high. Keep apprised as these values continue to change.

Which Matters More: Color or Clarity?

The argument against diamond color vs clarity is unnecessarily confusing for consumers. Together, clarity and color affect how a diamond looks. How much each of those traits matters varies widely by cut, by context, and by personal taste.

Experts agree, however, that the cut style is the most important factor. In situations like emerald cuts with wide-open faces that put inclusions in plain view, clarity wins out. This is in part because round cuts more effectively mask imperfections than other shapes, accentuating contrast between shades as our eyes are drawn to it.

Budgeting: Where to Compromise

In fact, that’s all most people want—the best value for their money. Just know that sometimes the price increase from a VS1 to an SI1 clarity grade can be pretty steep. Though the difference might be hard to notice, it can make a significant difference to your bottom line.

At times even two grades lower are perfectly acceptable when trying to save some money while still having a beautiful stone. Target your budget on a better cut instead, because a deep colored diamond, with a good cut, will conceal imperfections and color more effectively.

Align your decisions with your own money budget so you achieve the maximum amount of attractive quality and cost efficiency.

Setting Style: What Shows More?

Depending on the style of the ring, one characteristic may be more prominent than the other. For example, prong settings tend to accentuate color, while bezel settings tend to hide it. Both pear and marquise cuts will show color or inclusions at their pointed ends.

Create the perfect aesthetic. When it comes to creating your ideal aesthetic, pairing the right stone with the right setting is key.

Your Personal Preference Rules

The actual decision comes down to what you like. Some consumers desire a very cool, icy-looking stone and some consumers are okay with a little warmth as long as the clarity is better.

Consider how you live each day—if you lead a busy, energetic life, you might prefer a stone with visible inclusions.

Our Expert Recommendation

Cut Matters Most When It Comes To Sparkle. For the majority of shoppers, an H-I color diamond with VS2-SI1 clarity offers appealing aesthetics and value.

As always, consult with a trusted jeweler for advice tailored to your individual needs.

Smart Diamond Buying Tips

Purchasing a diamond is no small endeavor, and the difference between being prepared and unprepared is immense. Understanding the 4Cs—Color, Clarity, Cut, and Carat Weight—allows buyers to understand what contributes to price and appearance.

Cut is the most important factor for sparkle and can alter how the diamond shines. By researching these basics prior to shopping, diamond buyers will be informed and empowered. It saves them from being cheated into paying for aspects of a diamond that aren’t easy to see right away.

Compare Diamonds Side-by-Side

Side by side comparison is essential to diamond shopping. It allows consumers to identify subtle variations in color and clarity that would be difficult to discern on their own.

For instance, a cushion cut will do a better job at camouflaging a subtle yellow tinge than a round cut. When comparing, check these:

• Color and clarity grades on grading reports

• How each diamond reacts under different lighting

• Any visible spots or cloudiness

• Shape and cut quality

• Price per carat

Side-by-side comparison reveals which one truly wins in practice, not just on paper.

Read Grading Reports Carefully

Consider that a grading report is your diamond’s birth certificate. It’s the grading report that shows you the color, clarity, cut, carat weight and any other flaws.

You want to buy from labs you can trust, like GIA or AGS. Pay special attention to clarity and color grades, but look at cut scores. A proper grading report will ensure that any buyer can know what they are paying for and avoid any unexpected surprises.

Why Viewing In Person Helps

Diamonds look different in person than online. Viewing these stones in natural light or jeweler’s case light reveals even the tiniest color tints or blemishes.

Looking with your eyes instead of trusting just made up grades. This is because buyers can instantly tell if a diamond is right for them.

Choose a Trusted Canadian Jeweller

Peace of mind comes from knowing your jewellery is made by a trusted Canadian jeweller. Area jewelers have a pulse on the local market and can help you decide on a cut, a metal band, the latest trends.

By offering grading reports and allowing buyers to compare diamonds side by side, they simplify the buying process and offer more transparency.

Conclusion

To select the right diamond for your personal aesthetic and financial priorities, use color and clarity as your main guides. Together, they influence how a diamond appears, but not all eyes see what’s most important first. Some people here in Toronto prefer a more colorless stone with a hint of warmth, others prefer fully pure white. Understand where you’re willing to compromise. Price increases dramatically with each grade increase, so figure out what’s most important to you. Don’t consider a grade as the final determination of a stone’s quality. Natural light really emphasizes the differences. For starters, ask questions. As always, trust your eye and gut. Responsible shopping, conscientious consumer. Need additional assistance with diamonds or jewelry? Call a jeweler in your area or stop into a store near you. When you have the right help, it can be so easy to find the perfect diamond.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does diamond color mean?

What does diamond color mean? Diamond color describes the degree to which a diamond looks colorless. Most diamonds are graded on a scale from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow or brown). Therefore, the less color, the higher value the diamond.

How is diamond clarity measured?

What is diamond clarity Diamond clarity is determined by the quantity, size, relief, nature and position of internal (inclusions) and external (blemishes) flaws. The GIA scale begins with Flawless (no visible inclusions) and goes down to Included (obvious imperfections).

Does diamond color or clarity matter more?

Both are definitely important, but for most buyers, color is more noticeable than clarity. In reality, a slightly lower color grade, near-colorless diamond with very small inclusions usually appears breathtaking and is a more affordable option.

Can you see diamond clarity flaws with the naked eye?

It’s worth noting that many clarity flaws are not visible unless magnified. Diamonds with a clarity grade of VS2 or higher will typically look flawless to the naked eye.

How do color and clarity affect diamond price?

How do color and clarity affect diamond price? Higher color and clarity grades raise a diamond’s price. Color is much more noticeable than clarity, making colorless diamonds more expensive than diamonds with very small inclusions.

What is the best diamond color for an engagement ring?

For the majority of ring settings, diamonds graded between G and I will look colorless and offer fabulous value for money. Pick a grade which appears white in your desired environment.

How can I get the best value when buying a diamond?

Instead, aim for the best value diamonds in the near-colorless range (G-H) and a clarity grade of at least VS2 or SI1. These provide the same stunning look and craftsmanship at a much better value than highest rankings.

We also offer an extensive collection of custom and stock rings:

• Engagements Rings

• Wedding Rings

• Ladies wedding rings 

• Men's wedding bands 

Let Mark Katzeff help you find what you want that not only inspires you but meets your budget. Call for a free consultation today!

Out Of Town Custom Jewellery Store Customers 

Mark Katzeff attracts clients from all over the world to visit his unique jewellery store in Edmonton, here are some of his top links in staying here when meeting with our team, try some of the other attractions!!

Places To Stay

Things To Do 

About Edmonton

Edmonton Resources 

Edmonton Shopping